Showing posts with label new media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label new media. Show all posts

Friday, October 22, 2010

Facebook: The Ultimate Relationship Killer?

Subtitle: This article will explore how social networks such as Facebook either hurt or help dating and relationships. I will explore how Facebook has played an important part in causing "drama" in relationships and also the ways such networking sites have brought lovers together.

When I googled "Facebook and relationships" in order to research for this weeks blog topic, I was shocked at the number of articles that came up in relation to these 2 search terms. There is clearly an overwhelming outcry in the world on how Facebook can interfere in relationships and dating. But yet, it doesn't stop people from going on Facebook. So I pose the question: how does Facebook help or hurt relationships and the dating process?

In order to conduct proprietary research for this topic, I posted a Facebook status (oh, the irony) that asked the same question above: how does Facebook help or hurt relationships and dating? And Why? Within 5 minutes, I had 7 comments to this status with people offering their opinion, some more vehemently than others. The number 1 complaint amongst users is that Facebook hurts relationships and dating because it is a "drama starter." Basically people feel that arguments or problems can be started as a result of actions or communications that are made through Facebook. One example that was shared with me was a boyfriend was using the social network to stay in touch with ex-girlfriends. On the surface, not such a crime, but he did so behind her back because since it was through Facebook, rather the cell phone or email, he thought that it would be more secure and private. This immediately made me do some research because it made me think, is this a problem that many people are experiencing? And sure enough, it is. I came across the perfect article as it connects to past lovers and social networking titled, "Past Loves and Facebook." You can read the article here: http://www.mentalhelp.net/poc/view_doc.php?type=doc&id=29039&cn=289. Author of the article, Elisha Goldstein, Ph. D, said, "In my own practice I've heard people finding past loves on Facebook who are currently in committed relationships and some of them begin a flirting/emotional relationship, and some don't. But one thing is clear; in some way, it inevitably gets in the way of the original physical relationship that is not in cyberspace." Personally, I think Facebook and cyberspace in general makes the ease of access to old flames the dangerous characteristic. Before all of these social networking sites, you might wonder what an old flame was doing but without directly communicating with them through a phone call or email, it stayed "a wonder". But now with these sites, it's so EASY to find anyone and to find out what they are doing, where they are and how they are doing, all with a few keystrokes.

Another reason given as to why Facebook is a "drama starter" is that people tend to read more into status posts than the writer intended, so leading to unnecessary and childish arguments. So in this way, Facebook can cause disagreements where there really isn't a disagreement.

But there were also many positive remarks! I spoke to a friend a few weeks ago while posing such questions to friends at a house party, and Dan supplied me with a great example of why Facebook is actually a good thing when it comes to dating. He told me that he recently had secured a date with an old classmate through Facebook. He said the social site helped in 2 ways: 1. He wouldn't have been able to reach her if he had not found her on Facebook because it had been many years since they went to school together. 2. He was able to invite her to coffee through Facebook itself, which he would not have been able to do since he did not have her cell phone number. Another great example was provided by Kelly when the central question above was posed to my own Facebook community. She said, "It helps! My boyfriend and I initially got to know each other through Facebook chat (after meeting in person). I think it was less "scary" to talk that way than in person when first feeling each other out. We were able to easily show each other pictures of our families and friends, and show our families and friends who the other person is." One last example, provided by Jim, who supports the notion that Facebook can actually help dating and relationships, "You can meet new people and have relationships online where you may not get the opportunity to meet them in person."

It is obvious that the question of Facebook as a variable in relationships and dating is one that provokes extensive emotion and debate. So what does it all boil down to? Wendy provided a great outlook to describe how Facebook helps or hurts dating in the following description: "I think it depends on the level of trust you have in your relationship. If you trust your partner, then there should be no worries about what or who she/he is talking about. If the trust is shaky then that opens up all the "who is she talking to on Facebook," "what does that status update really mean" kind of stuff." What a surprise, it boils down to trust. And at the end of the day, whether it is Facebook, Myspace, cell phones or any other new technology that aides in immediate and extensive communication, the basic foundation to any good relationship is trust. In today's world, there may be exponentially new ways to reach anyone and communicate with them, but the primary building block of trust and confidence in your partner is still the secret to success in relationships.

I leave you with some further reading, with an article titled "5 Ways to keep Myspace and Facebook from Ruining Your Relationship." (http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/1369897/5_ways_to_keep_myspace_and_facebook.html?cat=41) This is good reading for those that think Facebook is a a cause for drama and in general good reading for all of us who frequent the social networking world (I included). You can read about each way more in depth through the link above but here are the 5 ways to keep Myspace and Facebook from Ruining YOUR relationship:
1. Set Up Ground Rules
2. Limit your Log Ins
3. Don't Take Advantage
4. Talk Before You Post
5. Weigh Your Options

Happy social networking!

Friday, October 1, 2010

Online Dating: Opportunity or Scam?

Subtitle: This post will discuss online dating and some of the implications that result from courting with this type of new media.

We've all seen the movies from the "classic" times; a young man falls in love with a young woman, and he jumps through all sorts of hoops to get her attention, leaving letters for her to read and doing sweet things to win her affection. In their day, those were the tools they had to utilize to gain someone's affection. Fast forward 80 years and now you have cell phones, laptops, Facebook, and many other vehicles to express affection for another, whether romantic or platonic. The first of these new media technologies I will discuss as it relates to courting is Online Dating (eharmony.com, match.com, etc.) and its implications. Here is an excellent article in which the NY Times discusses Online Dating and the science behind it (http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/29/science/29tier.html).

In the article, Dr. Buckwalter, a psychologist who had previously been a research professor at the University of Southern California, asserts that online dating works because it matches personality similarities and diminishes the differences between partners that can often lead to arguments and disagreements. “We’re not looking for clones, but our models emphasize similarities in personality and in values,” Dr. Buckwalter said. “It’s fairly common that differences can initially be appealing, but they’re not so cute after two years. If you have someone who’s Type A and real hard charging, put them with someone else like that. It’s just much easier for people to relate if they don’t have to negotiate all these differences.”

Online dating has spread like wildfire. Once considered awkward and potentially dangerous, online dating is now a popular tool in the hunt for everlasting love. But is it? I think online dating has merit: there is a system that pairs you with like-minded individuals and matches you based on a set of criteria that you have deemed "important." Then on a daily basis, these matches are delivered to you via an online interface and you are able to communicate with these people using set communication steps that are established by the online service you use. Sounds like a great way to meet people that have common interests! But has it made it "too easy" for guys and girls to engage in communications with multiple people, taking away the element of enabling a "committed relationship"? It's right there, you are more than welcome to have communications with multiple matches at one time, and it's not like the different matches know about each other. Or do they?

This week, my girl friend (we'll call her B), who subscribes to eharmony, had an experience with online dating that she would sure like to forget, and for sure has made her a cynic from here on out. She had been using eharmony for about a month. She started talking with two individuals, we'll call them T and R. After going through the motions, she went out on a date with T, who was very nice but just didn't have what she was looking for in terms of a mate. Then she went on a date with R, with whom she felt much more compatible with. She went out with R multiple times and was really starting to think that this could go somewhere. Enter B's girl friend P whom she had convinced to join eharmony after a string of bad dating incidents. B and P had been exchanging eharmony stories and sharing their experiences, so much so that B showed P the profile and pictures of R to show her friend how much he had going for him, how cute he was, etc. (Girls love their girlfriend's opinion when it comes to guys). B had told P to great length about R and how well things were going. So one night, P goes onto her eharmony to check out some recent communications that had been delivered, and wouldn't you know: R had requested communication! P was floored. For one, she was starting to think that R was a nice guy, so happy for her friend B who seemed happy. And now she had to have that awkward communication with her friend and say, "So R is apparently still on the market and actively searching..." much to her dismay.

This is just one example of the implications of new media as it relates to courting in the 21st century. Individuals now have SO many options when it comes to dating that how does one know when they are "the one" for someone else or just "one of many"? Do you think R would have had the ability to court 2, 3 or 10 different ladies at once with only a pen and paper? Another question that the NY Times article above brings up is this notion of "knowing what you want" and when it comes to love, can we write down a list of "wants" and when that person arrives know they are your Prince Charming? “They think they know what they want,” Dr. Finkel said in the above NY Times article. “But meeting somebody who possesses the characteristics they claim are so important is much less inspiring than they would have predicted.”